| The menu at Jim's Steaks on South Street. |
I started this trip as a cheesesteak virgin. My first and only encounter with this meaty phenomenon was in early 2008, when a friend allowed me a bite of his lunchtime sandwich. It was ordered from a nearby deli that promised "authentic Philly cheesesteaks" (despite the fact that we were in Midtown Manhattan) and the one that had been delivered looked - and smelled - delicious: bits of beef snuggled tightly in a half a baguette, with American cheese oozing over the sides in all its gooey yellow glory.
I took a bite.
I chewed.
I chewed a little more.
I chewed further still.
I chewed what had been chewed and chewed that again.
I chewed so long and so hard that it started to seem less cheesesteak and more horse hoof, and my hapless jaws were mechanical grinders pulverizing the hoof into tasteless bits of gristle. Naturally, I was repulsed. Our friendship suffered.
It would be four years until cheesesteak once again seemed like a viable food source, and only because I had been told by locals and visitors alike that there was one cheesesteak that could turn on any unbeliever: Jim's Steaks on South Street, only a few blocks down from the Magic Gardens.
| The entrance to Jim's Steaks on South Street. |
I went alone to Jim's - Dan, a vegetarian, had begged off the excursion, saying he would take a walk and return when I was done. (Later I found out it was just an excuse to go buy my birthday present - such a nice fella I have.) There was a long line of brawny men in front of me, and they quickly ordered sandwiches and took their places at seats nearby. The man behind the counter asked what I wanted.
"A cheesesteak please, with provolone."
He sighed. Clearly I'd never done this before. "You want peppers? Onions? Mayonnaise?"
"Yes to peppers and onions, no to mayonnaise." (Mayonnaise is gelatinous and disgusting, and I cannot be convinced otherwise. Don't try.)
I scooted down the line to allow the next person to order. The woman at the register wanted to know what beverage would I like, so I requested a cherry soda. It seemed appropriate.
She handed me my sandwich. It felt heavy. I turned around to look for a place to sit, and one of the men moved their jacket to offer me a seat. I thanked him and began to unwrap my sandwich.
| A cheese steak with all the fixings, and a side of Dr. Brown's Black Cherry soda. |
The bread was warm and crisp. He had laid the provolone in neat squares along the side. The onions and peppers rested atop the frizzled meat. The aroma was primal, intoxicating.
I took a bite. And, without warning, succumbed immediately to a phenomenon best described as "Cheese-Steak-Induced-Crazy-Eye-Feeding-Frenzy."
| Evidence of Cheese Steak Crazy Eyes. You know it's happening if you cannot, for the life of you, manage to take a clear photo because it's sitting there, watching, waiting to be eaten. |
Shamed as I am to admit this in public, I gobbled the entire thing in less than ten minutes - and this thing was truly man-sized. Straight up: one of the brawny guys next to me saw me finish it, then nodded and made that frowny face that is actually a smile of approval. Do you know what I'm talking about? Such a difficult gesture to explain . . .
Anyway, you could make the case that I didn't actually "find" the best cheesesteak in Philadelphia - if anything, that cheesesteak found me. Hard. And, man, am I glad it did.
| Inside the Eyes Gallery. |
Later I headed to the Eyes Gallery next door - they have all manner of intriguing goodies for the touching (and purchasing, should you be so inclined). Indian textiles, Mexican folk art, Moroccan lamps, and an awesome selection of handmade and vintage women's clothing and accessories. I didn't realize it at the time, but the Eyes Gallery is actually owned and curated by Julia Zagar - the wife of Isaiah Zagar, the mosaic artist behind the Magic Gardens. Pop in if you have a chance.
Okay, bye!
Jim's Steaks is located at 400 South Street, Philadelphia. The Eyes Gallery is located at 402 South Street, Philadelphia - right next door.
Okay, bye!
Jim's Steaks is located at 400 South Street, Philadelphia. The Eyes Gallery is located at 402 South Street, Philadelphia - right next door.











